Posts Tagged ‘Virginia’

Lives well lived, as well as facts well learned

June 28th, 2010

Submitted here on Monday, June 28th, 2010, in response to this and this.

Dear Governor McDonnell,

I write to urge you to spend an equal amount of political capital on establishing new charter schools in Virginia as you do on attracting national charter operators to the state. Organizations like KIPP offer college-prep curriculums augmented by extra time and stringent expectations of student compliance with rules. However, they do not in and of themselves offer models of project-based learning and student-centered pedagogies that better develop students’ collaborative and problem-solving skills – skills students will need to lead their own communities, businesses, and service organizations.

Consider Microsoft’s Educational Competencies, or compare the Top 10 Reasons to Work at Google with KIPP’s Five Pillars. We have schools like KIPP that reflect strict adherence to traditional instruction; do we have school’s that reflect the cultures of our world’s information-age pioneers? How do we develop those schools?

We develop them by taking advantage of Virginia’s relative inexperience with the national charter movement to innovate truly new types of schools. As state and local school boards partner with national charter operators that focus on replicating traditional notions of college preparedness, we should develop in parallel charter schools that research, develop, and share-out innovative cultures, communities, and practices – practices that allow students to discover new learning while still enrolled in public schools. Imagine schools that allow students to contribute to their communities, not just to graduate from them. Imagine schools that empower students to teach adults, not just to follow them. Imagine schools that inspire students to create and discover, not just to accept and cover.

As you search for viable models of charter education in Virginia, please look to programs like the Maine Farm Enterprise School, the New Country School and our own Blue Ridge Virtual Governor’s School for models of assessment, community, curriculum, and instruction that take students’ learning outside the classroom.

Virginia communities have wants and needs addressed by programs like KIPP. Be certain, though, that our children need more than academic preparedness to lead joyful, fulfilling lives of service to their communities, state, nation, and world. To serve others students must feel strong enough themselves to seek out new solutions to the problems with which we’ll leave them. We need schools that help students realize their potentials as artists, designers, engineers, entrepreneurs, leaders, volunteers, and visionaries – schools that don’t accept the limits of a college-prep curriculum – however effectively delivered – as the limits of teaching and learning. We need schools that look for the results of lives well lived, as well as the results of facts well learned.

Please use your political capital to lift up children and new models of education that serve them and their communities through innovative, project- and community-based learning and new assessment measures that accurately capture the results of this work. Please help Secretary Robinson to continue his efforts to do the same. It was wonderful to visit with him at my school, the Community Public Charter School, in Albemarle County. I enthusiastically invite you both to visit my classroom and to join with me in talking with Virginia’s students, parents, and educators about why we educate our children, as well as about how we can educate our children better.

Sincerely,

Chad Sansing, NBCT

Two Takes on National Education Standards

June 3rd, 2009

By Norman Leahy

Responding to word that, at least in principle, 45 states and DC have agreed to the creation of a new set of national education standards, the Richmond Times-Dispatch coos:

The common-standards endeavor might complicate the effort of charter-school advocates who have been encouraged by President Obama’s openness to their cause. But it need not be a stumbling block. For one thing, wide disagreement about what kids should learn and when means any nationwide standards the states agree upon likely will set bare minimums. More to the point, the common standards will define a common finish line for each grade level. How schools get the students to cross it can still be up to them.


So all you school choicers — don’t worry your pretty little heads over this. Yes, it might make things tougher for you, but then again, maybe it won’t.

And, naturally, Virginia will benefit because the SOLs are already so rigorous that these new standards just might force those slackers elsewhere to catch-up.

Ah, the SOLs. The faith placed in bubble tests by the local gentry would be charming, or even mildly amusing…except for the manipulation of SOL data and the rather unimpressive showing of Virginia students on that already in-place national standard, the SAT.

“Bare minimums” indeed.

But another, and far less blinkered, view of national standards comes from Cato’s Neal McCluskey, who writes:

…when establishing national standards was attempted in the 1990s the real fireworks didn’t begin until proposed standards were published. Then, it seemed that everyone had a different reason they were outraged – outraged! – by the standards. At best, there was only one point of broad consensus: that the wannabe national standards simply had to go.

So are national standards a serious threat? They sure are: Were they to be enacted, the educationally deadly government-schooling monopoly would be complete, with even the ability to escape to better districts or states cut off.

But, he’s not overly concerned these standards will ever see the light of day, given the fractiousness of the parties involved.

We shall see.

(cross-posted at Tertium Quids)

Switch to our mobile site