It’s Not about the Technology

April 19th, 2009 by kellyhines Leave a reply »

(By Kelly W. Hines, Keeping Kids First)

I am sitting here at my laptop, occasionally watching my Skype and Tweetdeck notifications in case I miss something from a family member or colleague, and I’m going to honestly tell you that learning in the 21st century is not about the technology. Blasphemy! my tech-savvy friends are saying. Six months ago I might have agreed, but today I’m more than willing to stand by my words.

We are hearing more and more talk recently about what learning and teaching will look like in the 21st century. What do we need to bring us into the future? What will our children need to know and be able to do? The first thing to comes to everyone’s mind is technology. We need computers. We need ipods. We need wireless connectivity. We need 1:1 initiatives. We need blogs, wikis and podcasts. While I completely agree with the fact that these are innovative tools for teaching and learning, I do not agree that these are the first things we need to initiate change in our classrooms.

Before anything else, the educational community (including state and national organizations, teacher preparation programs, and local systems) must recognize the need to change an overall approach to teaching and learning. The tools mentioned earlier, like netbooks, 1:1 initiatives, and web 2.0 tools, will not be effective vehicles for instruction without an evolution in mindset. Here is a list of four things that every teacher must recognize in order to effectively and positively impact students in a new generation of learning.

1. Teachers must be learners. As teachers, most of us have completed a specialised teacher preparation program. We have passed a test of proficiency in basic educational theory and child psychology. We have demonstrated mastery of our own content areas. Think about the teachers in your building. The years that these teachers have exited these initial requirements span decades. If you put them all in one room, you will probably find that their experiences in these areas were very different. Yet, they are all teaching children today. Teachers today must be perpetual learners who are invested in their professions. We must be up to date on current trends, research and tools. We must know what our students are doing and where they are coming from when they enter our classrooms. This learning cannot just include mandated workshops and occasional required readings. Teachers who want to be truly succesful must be voracious and self-motivated in their pursuit of evoloving understanding.

2. Learning and Teaching are not the same thing. How many times have we heard a colleague say, “I don’t know why these kids don’t get it. I’ve taught it a hundred times.” I equate teaching and learning to a basic physics principle. If an object does not move, no matter how much force has been applied, no work has been done. Therefore, if a student has not learned, not matter how much effort has been exerted, no teaching has been done. Teaching in the 21st century is going to be about working smarter and not harder. It is not about adding to our proverbial plates. We must look at learning as the product of a successful day. Learning will not look the same to all students or all teachers, but it must be the goal.

3. Technology is useless without good teaching. We have countless technological tools at our disposable today. These tools range in cost from free to thousands and thousands of dollars. When we put innovative tools in the hands of innovative teachers, amazing things can happen. If you put these tools in the hands of teachers who are not willing to innovate, money has been wasted. There are arguments against spending the money on interactive whiteboards for classrooms. At approximately $5000 each, you would think these boards would facilitate better teaching. It is not about the board. It is about proper training and mindset of a teacher who is already willing and eager to do amazing things. The lack of comprehensive and curriculum-related professional development for teachers is why schools have thousands of computers that are being used as game systems and word processors.

4. Be a 21st Century Teacher without the technology. The Partnership for 21st Century Skills has published a framework for learning in the 21st century. The core outcomes for students include:

1. Core Subjects and 21st Century Themes
2. Learning and Innovation Skills
* Creativity and Innovation
* Critical Thinking and Problem Solving
* Communication and Collaboration
3. Information, Media and Technology Skills
* Information Literacy
* Media Literacy
* ICT Literacy
4. Life and Career Skills

Upon careful consideration, these are outcomes that can be achieved with little technology (excluding of course some components of the Information, Media and Technology Skills). If a teacher can find ways to prepare students with the capacity to be creative and innovative, those children will be well prepared to face the future. Teachers who customize the learning experiences of their students to involve critical thinking and problem solving are doing their students a greater favor than those who misuse technology as a means of facilitating learning. Those teachers who know how to foster communication and collaboration within their classrooms and school buildings are equipping their students with the abilities to apply these core skills to more areas in their own lives.

Now imagine a classroom where the teacher has embraced these principles. The teacher is a learner. The teacher teaches with learning in mind. 21st century skills are highlighted through facilitative leadership. These foundational components of a quality classroom experience will ensure that students value experiential and focused learning. Now if you take this teacher and introduce them to the wonders that technology offers for students, the possibilities are endless. But, it really is not about the technology.

No related posts.

Advertisement

518 comments

  1. Sterlingstrom says:

    Hey! I loved reading your blogpost. I am a student at the University of South Alabama in Dr. Strange’s EDM 310 class, and I was assigned to read your blog and comment on my blog. I will be writing a response on my blog after reading your blog. Check it out of you like http://stromsterlingedm310.blogspot.com

  2. Regina Simmons says:

    Ms. Hines, I agree with you that learning in the 21st century is not all about the technology after I read your blog post. Technology is just a tool and it is useless without inspired teachers and guidance. I am so pleased that my professor Dr.Strange asked me to read your blog. I will be writing a reflection on your post on my page and I hope you get a chance to check it out. http://simmonsreginaedm310.blogspot.com
    http://simmonsreginaedm310.blogspot.com/

  3. Darlenestaimpel says:

    As one of your followers I agree that technology is a great tool. The educator is the best tool. It is important to have the basic foundations in which to grow and succeed. I would like to invite you to visit my blog where I will be posting a reflection of your blog. http://staimpeldarleneedm310.blogspot.com

  4. Oshjayingkay says:

    Mrs. Hines, I thought your post was very intriguing. What I’ve taken from your post is that being a 21st century is not about technology but about a mindset. Also, using modern technology in the classroom requires us to be innovative teachers. More of my thoughts and perceptions will be at

  • F Nicole Kelley says:

    Ms. Hines, this is a very good blog and I enjoyed it very much! I’m in Dr. Strange’s EDM310 class and if you would like to see my complete comment about your blog check out my blog. http://kelleyfrancesedm310.blogspot.com

  • Ashley JeanAnn says:

    Mrs. Hines, I thought your blog was very interesting. It made a lot of good points. I learned a lot from it and I hope that by reading it I will be a better teacher in the future. I am in Dr. Strange’s EDM 310 class. If you would like to see my comment about your blog check out mine. http://ashleyjeanannedm310.blogspot.com

  • Flemingelizabethb says:

    Ms. Hines, I really liked your blog and totally agree with what you have said in it. I am in Dr. Strange’s EDM310 class and am hopefully learning some about all of this new technology so that I can use it in the classroom. If you would like to see my comment about your blog check out my blog. http://flemingelizabethedm310.blogspot.com

  • Caitlyn Lord says:

    Mrs. Hines, I am a student in Dr. Strange’s EDM310 course at South Alabama and I am also following another one of your blogs for his class. I just wanted to say that I agree with your post and only through teachers learning to teach, will the school system achieve the goals it needs to be setting. If you would like to see my comments for this post or any other comments I have made about your other posts check out my blog at http://lordcaitlynedm310.blogspot.com

  • Brittany Schneider says:

    Ms. Hines, I am also a student in Dr. Strange’s EDM310 class at the University of South Alabama. I agree that teachers must be willing to learn to be able to properly teach. My comments about your post can be found on my blog: http://schneiderbrittanyedm310.blogspot.com

  • Mitch Pouliot says:

    Hi Mrs. Hines, I am also a student in EDM310 at the University of South Alabama. I agree 100% that “It’s Not about the Technology”. I’m simultaneously amazed at the resources that my wife’s first grade class has available, and the number of teachers reluctant to utilize it. Thank you for your insight. If your interested in reading my blog you can view it at http://pouliotmitchedm310.blogspot.com

  • Ryne Baxter says:

    Ms. Hines, I am a student in Dr. Strange’s EDM310 class at the University of South Alabama. I agree that technology is useless without good teaching and it surprises me that a lot of teachers are reluctant to learning about or using all the new technology. This was an excellent post and you can find the rest of my comments at Ryne’s Blog

  • Watsontara09 says:

    Hi, Mrs. Hines. My name is Tara Watson and I am a student in Dr. Strange’s EDM310 class. I have been quite nervous about all of the technology and thoughts I’ve had about how I would personally connect teaching with technology, but your post brings me relief. It does require a good teacher in order for technology to even matter in the classroom, and I’m glad you pointed that out. You can read my further comments at Tara’s Blog

  • Leigh Setser says:

    Hi Mrs. Hines! My name is Leigh Setser and I am a student stuying elementary education at the University of South Alabama. I read your post as an assignment for my EDM 310 with Dr. Strange. We are learning a lot about technology and the many ways we can incorporate it into our teaching. I have been learning a lot about being an effective teacher and your post has added more information to my brain as what an effective teacher is. I think your post is an excellent example of how an effective teacher needs to have technology skills for their students and classroom and other “traditional” skills in order to get their students learning. Thank you for making my wheels turn! If you would like to read some of my posts or comments you can find me at http://setserleighedm310.blogspot.com/

    Thank you!

  • Jenny Black says:

    Hey Dr. Hines,

    I am ALSO a student at South Alabama in Dr. Strange’s EDM 310 class. One of my favorite things that you said in this post is , “Learning will not look the same to all students or all teachers, but it must be the goal.” I just LOVE that quote. I think you could become famous for that one sentence. I think it is going to stick with me in how I think about teaching forever. If you would like to read more of my thoughts about your blog, you can do so here: http://blackjennyedm310.blogspot.com/

    Thanks for the great post!

    Jenny Black

  • Ali Reynolds says:

    Ms. Hines, I am a student in Dr. Strange’s EDM310 class at the University of South Alabama. I agree that learning and teaching are not the same thing. Some students just do not understand things as easily as others. Teachers should focus on ways to make it easier for these students to learn. My comments about your post can be found at http://reynoldsaliedm310.blogspot.com.
    Thanks for sharing,
    Ali Reynolds

  • Shellie Miller says:

    Ms. Hines,

    As a current studnet of Dr. Strange’s EDM 310 class at the University of South Alabama in Mobile, I had the opportunity to read this post as one of my assignments. Your post was extremely on point in regards that we as an educational community must first change our mindset in order to successfully put our children first. The point that you mentioned about how “technology is useless without good teaching” could not be more perfect. Thank you for your post which helps illuminate where we as teachers should be for our students.
    I have made additional comments about your post and other interesting posts at my blog, Shellie’s Blog

  • Margeaux says:

    Hi Ms. Hines. I am a student in Dr. Strange’s EDM310 class as well. This couldn’t have been better written. I think that wanting to teach your children the foundations of learning is critical. Everything else will come into play over time. To read my comments on your post, you can visit my blog at http://estevanemargeauxedm310.blogspot.com
    Thank You for sharing your ideas!

  • Sarah Pierce says:

    Mrs. Hines, I am a student in Dr. Strange’s EDM310 class and have read your post as part of an assignment. My comments can be found at my blog: http://piercesarahedm310.blogspot.com/

  • Leslie Roberson says:

    Ms. Hines I am a student at South Alabama and part of my assignment was to read your blog for Mr. Strange’s EDM 310. You can see my comments on my blog http://robersonleslieedm310.blogspot.com/

  • Laura Scott says:

    Hey Ms. Hines, I really enjoyed your post! I am a student of Dr. Strange’s EDM310 class and you can read my comments on my blog

  • Laura Scott says:

    my blog address is http://scottlauraedm310.blogspot.com/ just in case it did not include it on my first comment.

  • Jambran806 says:

    Ms. Hines,
    Your post was both very entertaining and enlightening to me. I don’t mean to make it sound as if I was laughing at your post; I was laughing at the image that ran through my mind as I was reading the post. I pictured a mother putting a Mac computer in front of an infant and telling him to learn. A Mac is great…. but only if you properly teach the child how to use it, which first requires you to have knowledge of the computer.
    As a future educator, I believe technology is an important element in the classroom. However, I agree with your claim (It isn’t about the technology). A teacher should be able to teach students how to be technologically literate without the technology in their hands. When they are finally given access to the technology, imagine what such a teacher will be able to accomplish.
    Too many of my own teachers abused the technology that was at their disposal. I don’t believe that they did intentionally, but they simply wee not innovative enough. In high school English class, I can not count the number of research papers I had to write. My teachers told me to research these people, “write a paper on the demolition of the rain forests in South America.” Looking back on it, I wish that I had known that, through technology (Podcasts, blogs, etc.), I could do my research by experiencing it. What a world of difference that would have made!
    I’m reading your post as a part of my EDM 310 Microcomputing Systems class with Dr. John Strange. All of my comments are posted to my class blog: http://branchjamesonedm310.blogspot.com/. Thanks for sharing! -Jameson Branch

  • Erie470 says:

    Ms. Hines. I have read your post as part of Dr. Strange’s EDM 310 assignment. As I began to read, at first I thought this was going to be a boring article fo some sort, and then I realized, I am in full agreement with everything you have said. Not enough teachers are willing to learn as well as teach. Teaching is useless if the teacher is not up to date with things such as technology. I couldn’t agree with you more! All of my comments are posted to my Class Blog http://tillmanerinedm310.blogspot.com/ if you would like to take a look?

  • Erie470 says:

    Ms. Hines. I have read your post as part of Dr. Strange’s EDM 310 assignment. As I began to read, at first I thought this was going to be a boring article fo some sort, and then I realized, I am in full agreement with everything you have said. Not enough teachers are willing to learn as well as teach. Teaching is useless if the teacher is not up to date with things such as technology. I couldn’t agree with you more! All of my comments are posted to my Class Blog http://tillmanerinedm310.blogspot.com/ if you would like to take a look?

  • Cody Coleman14 says:

    Hi Ms. Hines, great post! I couldnt agree more with your views. I am in Dr. Strange’s EDM 310 class and you can read my comments on my blog. http://colemancodyedm310.blogspot.com/

  • Samantha Deardorff says:

    Ms. Hines,
    I have enjoyed reading your post. I read it as for Dr. Strange’s EDM 310 class. You can read my comments on your post on my blog: http://deardorffsamanthaedm310.blogspot.com/

  • Noeline Wright says:

    I agree. Her’s some New Zealand research to support your point of view: http://www.educationcounts.govt.nz/publications/ict/77614

  • Sherrie Spence says:

    Hi Mrs. Hines,
    I am a student of Dr. Strange in EDM 310 at University of South Alabama. I am commenting as part of an assignment. I really enjoyed reading this post. I like how you point out how a teacher must be a learner. I think that just like to teachers have been taught ways to be creative and innovative without technology, they can be taught how to teach with it. You can also look on our class blog: http://edm310.blogspot.com/. My blog is http://spencesherrieedm310.blogspot.com/

  • Alexis Moore says:

    Ms. Hines,
    Your blog really made me think. Technology is great, but you are right when you say it’s not everything. I agree that teachers have to want to do great things and have new ideas. I am also one of Dr. Strange’s students for EDM 310 at the University of South Alabama. My comments of your blog can be found at http://moorealexisedm310.blogspot.com/.

  • Tabitha Sexton says:

    Ms Hines,
    I have always agreed with this view point. It is not always about the technology, however I do believe it is important, But it is not just the technology that makes these children learn, it is the teacher who gives the encouragement and creativity to be who they are. I am commenting as part of an assignment from Dr. Strange’s EDM 310 class. Below I have given you my blog URL and you can go there and look at my response.
    http://sextontabithaedm310.blogspot.com/

  • Teri Hampton says:

    Hi Ms. Hines,

    I’m an Elementary Ed. major at the University of South Alabama. I’m currently in Dr. Strange’s EDM 310 class and one of our assignments is that we read your blog. I also believe that technology is useless without a great teacher who knows how to use the technology properly. I will be posting additional comments to my blog, which can be found at http://hamptonteriedm310fall2010.blogspot.com/

  • AnMarie Lane says:

    Hi Mrs. Hines! I am an elementary education major at the University of South Alabama and have been assigned to read your blog in Dr. Strange’s EDM 310 class. After reading your post, I was so happy to realize that not everyone in the teaching field is doing everything strictly with all of the new technology. As you said, technology does not really mean too much if there is not a good teacher behind it. I am personally not too technologically literate and have felt a little bit overwhelmed from time to time with what I will have to with technology in my future classroom. Reading your post made me feel a little bit better because it reassured me that, while technology is important in the classroom, it is not the most important thing. You can find other comments that I will be posting on my blog, which can be found at my blog

  • Lawanna Hinton says:

    Hi Ms. Hines, I’m an Elementary Ed. major at the University of South Alabama and have been assigned this post in Dr. Strange’s EDM310 class. After reading your post I agree with the fact that teaching is a continuing learning process. We have to be willing to learn new things so we can teach our students new and exciting things, especially technology. You can also see more post in my blog http://lhinton79edm310.blogspot.com

  • Matthew Miller says:

    Hello Ms. Hines, I am a student at the University of South Alabama and have been assigned to read this post for Dr. Strange’s class. I was so happy to read your post because I have been thinking the same thing for a while now. I sort of get tired of hearing how all teachers need to be geniuses with a computer. I have had a ton of awesome teachers who never knew how to work a PowerPoint. However, I definitely feel like we as teachers should be able to learn about the new technology available to us. I also have a blog that you can check out http://www.blogger.com/post-create.g?blogID=7857452104331168619 . Great article!

  • Lauren Myrick says:

    Ms. Hines,
    I am a student at The University of South Alabama and have been assigned to read your post in Dr. Strange’s EDM310 class,and I am delighted that I did. I agree that it takes the teacher’s willingness to create a better learning environment. Technology is useless if a teacher does not have the knowledge to use it, or use it in a creative manner. I will post more about what I think about this post and you can visit my blog post Here

  • Hi Ms.Hines, I am currently enrolled in Dr. Strange’s EDM 310 class and we were given your post to read it and I found it was very informative and makes you think about the reality of technology and teaching. I will be commenting about your post on my blog which you can follow at: http://mathenymalissaedm310.blogspot.com/ if you like.

  • Amberli Chastng says:

    Hi Ms. Hines,
    I’m an Elementary Ed. major at the University of South Alabama. I’m currently in Dr. Strange’s EDM 310 class and one of our assignments is that we read your blog. I agree that technology is nothing without the proper skills necessary to create and teach. I will be posting additional comments to my blog, which can be found at http://chastangamberliedm310.blogspot.com/

  • Brandi Alexander says:

    Hi, Ms. Hines. I am commenting on this particular post as an assignment for Dr. John Strange’s EDM310 class at the University of South Alabama in Mobile, Alabama. I agree with you when you say that technology is useless without good teaching. It takes cooperation from the teachers to learn about uses of technology to prove positive outcome in the classroom and also cooperation from the students to want to learn and engage in the technological revolution. Some additional comments for this post can be viewed at my class blog

  • Brandi Alexander says:

    the link to my blog appears to not be working properly. The URL is alexanderbrandilynnedm310@blogspot.com

  • Kristin Key says:

    Ms. Hines, I enjoyed reading your post. Thank you for helping us put the focus back on the teacher and their role in the classroom. However much influence technology has in our education system, I hope it will never be able to replace the teacher. You can read my comments if you wish for Dr. Strange’s EDM 310 Class on my blog: http://keykristinedm310.blogspot.com

  • Tarvaries says:

    Hi Mrs Hines, i really enjoyed your awesome post! I read your post as an assignment for Dr. Strange’s EDM310 class, you can read my response on my blog at http://reasetarvariesedm310.blogspot.com/ thanks!

  • Kayla L Salas says:

    Hi Ms. Hines. Your post was great! I am so glad someone is finally putting teaching AND learning back on the teachers instead of the technology. I read your post as an assignment for Dr. Strange’s EDM 310 class. I will be writing a response about your post about my blog which you can find here:http://salaskaylaedm310.blogspot.com/ Thank You!

  • Callieramz says:

    Hi Ms. Hines, I’m an Elementary Education major at the University of South Alabama and have been assigned to read your post in Dr. Strange’s EDM310 class. After reading your post I agree with the fact that teaching is a process that we must continually be willing to learn new things. We have be able to keep learning fun and exciting so that we can help students stay interested and to know that learning is always changing. We do need to learn about people of our past but also about people changing the world now. You can also see more of my post at http://ramseycallieedm310.blogspot.com

  • Ann-Marie New says:

    You are right in the idea that teaching tools are useless in the hands of a person that does not teach. Students can learn. They may all learn differently, but they learn. The same is for teachers. The approach may vary. In the end, it is about knowing how to come across to the students. Once a teacher is able to do that, the possibilities are endless. I want to teach for the military in the future. I am sure that that field will vary so much when compared to teaching public schools. But I will approach it just the same. Students are students. They all can learn. They all come to learn. It is my responsibility to come prepared to teach. On a side note, I was directed to your site by my EDM310 instructor, Dr. Strange. My class has blogs of our own. You can visit mine to see my review of your posting if you want. http://newannmarieedm310.blogspot.com/

  • Rachel Ward says:

    Ms. Hines,

    I attend the University of South Alabama. My EDM 310 professor, Dr. Strange, has instructed me to read and comment on your post.

    It can be found here: http://wardracheledm310.blogspot.com/

    I really enjoyed what you said!

  • Jameica York says:

    Hey Ms. Hines. This was a great post. I am in Dr. Strange’s EDM 310 class. You can read my comments about your post on my blog. http://yorkjameicaedm310.blogspot.com

  • Kristen Hayes says:

    Mrs. Hines,
    I am also in Dr. Strange’s EDM 310 class. You can read my comment about your post on my blog
    http://hayeskristenedm310.blogspot.com/

  • Leviticus Wilson says:

    I am from Dr. Strange’s EDM 310 class at the University of South Alabama. I really enjoyed your blog. It made me think about the future of education in a way that I have never thought about it before. You can visit more of my response at http://wilsonleviticusedm310.blogspot.com/ . Thank you!

  • Len Jenkins says:

    I have read your post as part of an assignment for Dr. Strange’s EDM 310 class and my comments can be found on my class blog. http://jenkinslenedm310.blogspot.com/

  • Katlyn says:

    Mrs. Hines,
    I really enjoyed reading your blog. I have read your post as part of an assignment for Dr. Strange’s EDM 310 class and my comments can be found on my class blog. http:hurtkatlynedm310.blogspot.com

  • Trackbacks /
    Pingbacks

    Leave a Reply

    *

    Switch to our mobile site